As we have discussed in class over the past week, the Western has been around since the beginning of the film industry. The concept of the “frontier,” something central to the genre, is a distinctly American idea. No other country has developed in such a way that a frontier remained on the national conscious for such an extended amount of time, providing the Western genre with a huge amount of potential material.
One thing that we’ve discussed thoroughly in class is how the Western typically shows civilization prevailing over the wild. The lone gunslinger must face off against the wild to protect the civilization in the film. I’m not entirely sure that I agree with this though. While it is undeniably true that civilization typically prevails in Westerns, it seems to me that the gunslinger archetype falls closer to the side of the wild than of civilization. While the gunslingers fight to restore/maintain order, they use decidedly uncivilized tactics to do so. In A Fistful of Dollars, the Man With No Name uses violence just as often as the bandits that he is fighting against. In The Proposal, an Australian Western released in 2009, the main character is a notorious bandit required to track down the leader of his gang (his older brother), in order to save the life of his younger brother. In both films, the protagonist definitely works on the side of civilization, but in a decidedly “wild way.” The fact that in almost every Western relies upon the hero utilizing violence to defend civilization seems to imply that it is only through embracing the wild that civilization can prevail.
For whatever reason, people tend not to think of films as historical documents. What’s odd about this though, is that movies are directly associated with when they were released. When we think of a movie, the first thing we think about is whether or not we liked it (obviously). After that though, we think about when we saw the film, and often, when it was released. When we describe films to people, we discuss the plot of the film, but often we add the year or decade that the film was released. Certain genres are even defined by the era in which they were released, such as ‘30s monster movies, the counter-culture films of the ‘70s, and the slasher flicks of the ‘80s.
As historians, we would be remiss if we dismissed the usefulness of films as historical documents. It’s common to hear students rejoice to learn “we watch a lot of movies” in a new class at the beginning of each semester, but movies present a unique way to study history. In just an hour and a half, we can learn much about a certain time period by watching a movie. We can watch A Knight’s Tale in order to learn about the culture of 14th century England. We can look at comedies released in the early 2000s and learn that people had no desire to see quality films. Movies posses a unique ability to make the audience interested in characters that can be hard to relate to. Geoffrey Chaucer is probably not an interesting person to people who aren’t interested in classic English literature. But in A Knight’s Tale, we care about Chaucer; we want Ulrich to cover his debts.
As with anything being interpreted as a historical source though, we must be careful what we accept as fact. Mel Gibson’s character in The Patriot is undeniably awesome. He is also undeniably made up. What Gibson’s character does throughout the film is actually a compilation of the works of multiple different soldiers.[1]Saving Private Ryan can be used as an examination of American patriotism, but it must be remembered that Steven Spielberg makes movies in order to make money, not to educate his audience about World War II.
Having knowledge of the history of film can be as useful to us, as historians, as using films as sources. By knowing how the movie industry developed, we are able to learn about people (speaking generally) in America. We can follow the way that people spent money at theaters and come to conclusions about how secure they felt economically at various times throughout history. We can examine the films being released, and the films being watched, and see what is socially acceptable in America at a certain time.
Talking about race in class yesterday, I couldn’t help but think about how blatant Hollywood used to be about its racism and how many African-American, and other minority actors have since become household names.
As we discussed in class yesterday, for much of its early life, Hollywood was decidedly white, if not our-right racist. In a segregated America, African-American actors were non-existent in Hollywood. White actors were typically put in black-face in order to portray African-American characters. Birth of a Nation (1915) features this type of casting prominently, as well as featuring the characters in black-face playing strongly into stereotypes of African-Americans.
After black-face became frowned upon publicly, Hollywood stopped portraying African-Americans with white actors, although they continued to portray other minorities this way. Breakfast at Tiffany’s (1961), features Mickey Rooney in the role of Mr. Yunioshi, Holly’s Asian upstairs neighbor. The way that Rooney portrays Yunioshi is near unbelievable in its racism.
Hollywood has become a place where minorities can thrive though. Some of the biggest names in film, whether actors or directors, are not Caucasian. Will Smith has become as close to a box-office guarantee as there is in Hollywood. Javier Bardem looks to be on the path to superstardom, following critically-acclaimed roles in No County for Old Men (2007) and Biutiful (2010). The director of last weekend’s number one film, Immortals, is Tarsem, who hails from India. Spike Lee, director of films like Do the Right Thing (1989) and Inside Man (2006), is well known for his outspokenness on race relations.
Since becoming more integrated, Hollywood has prospered. Minority actors and directors (and other jobs in the industry) have provided a wealth of talent and ideas that Hollywood was originally closing itself off from.
When we were discussing the commonly accepted view of technology in class, we provided numerous examples of films that showed that humanity is scared of technology. We discussed how films such as Minority Report (2002), Terminator (1984), and Demolition Man (1993) show how we obviously fear technology, as technology is the main antagonist in each of these films. And we seemed to support this claim, when we were unable to provide any examples of pro-technology movies. At the time of the discussion, this assessment didn’t really sit right with me, although I found myself unable to articulate an argument against the consensus. But as we were watching part of Fail-Safe, a certain quote stated what I was trying to get at. When he is on the phone with the Russian Premiere, The American President (played by Henry Fonda) states that “we let our machines get out of hand.” When the Russian Premiere claims that no one is to blame for the situation, as the machines simply malfunctioned. Fonda dismisses this claim, saying “We’re responsible for what happens to us.” When I heard this exchange, I understood how I could approach this topic. It isn’t that we are afraid of technology; rather we are afraid of losing control of technology, which often happens because of things that we do.
In all of the movies we discussed, and some examples that I’ll get into, humanity finds itself set upon by rampant technology. But it is often the case that this only happens after we make mistakes that allow the technology to get out of control. Further, we often have to depend upon the technology to save us from our quandary. In Minority Report, the police use “pre-cogs,” essentially psychics, to predict crimes and stop them before they happen. Police Chief John Anderton (Tom Cruise) is accused of murdering a man that he has never met, and, as a result of this, runs from the law, attempting to clear his name. We come to find out that he is being framed by his boss, who is attempting to cover up a murder that he has committed. In The Terminator, a robot is sent into the past to kill the mother of the child that will eventually lead the revolution that frees humanity from slavery at the hands of the Terminators. He fails, and in the sequel, a Terminator is used to protect the child. Demolition Man centers on the idea that criminals will be frozen instead of killed, leading to a notorious criminal being thawed out in the future. The only way to capture him is to thaw out another criminal to go after him. In I, Robot the robots attempt to take control of humanity, but are stopped by a duo of a cyborg cop (Will Smith), and a robot.
It also seems that there are more pro-technology films than immediately come to mind. Steven Spielberg’s A.I.: Artificial Intelligence (2001) follows a robot child as he attempts to find a place to belong. Through the course of the movie he is tormented by his human “brother,” abandoned by his human “mother,” and sees a carnival where robots are torn to pieces for the entertainment of a human crowd. Blade Runner (1982) focuses on Deckard (Harrison Ford) as he attempts to track down a group of replicants (robots) who have returned to Earth to find a way to re-write their programming, which is set to kill them after 4 years of life. They are hunted down and killed due to the fact that they are simply trying to survive a death visited upon them by humanity. Watch as Roy Batty, the leader of the replicants comes to accept his fate:
These are not the words of some lifeless automaton, but those of a “man” who has knowledge of life and death and, accordingly, fears death.
It seems to me that the only time we should truly fear technology is when we act inhumanely towards it. If we give robots, terminators, or replicants a reason to fear for their well-being, then they will not attempt to enslave us. These movies serve more as warnings against what will happen when we abuse the technology that we have created to help us than as warnings against the technology itself.
Watching Blackboard Jungle in class on Tuesday, I couldn’t help but be reminded of a certain genre of movies that was fairly popular earlier this decade: the urban drama. These films (Save the Last Dance, Coach Carter, Take the Lead, Step Up) were set in the inner city and featured some sort of cultural clash. And while they were rarely anything special, they are almost universally watchable (a level of praise that should not be discounted).
What is striking about these films is that they all feature an uplifting story line. In Save the Last Dance, Julia Stiles’ character overcomes her initial outcast status in her new outcast status through a shared love of dance and, not only does she get a boyfriend, she gains the courage to follow her dream to be a ballerina. In Coach Carter, a basketball coach returns to his alma mater and attempts to take a horrible basketball team and make them successful. For him this starts in the classroom and at one point he locks the team out of the gym, causing outrage in the community. Take the Lead feature Antonio Banderas as a dance teacher who takes over the detention period at a New York City high school, and attempts to teach his students about life through ballroom dance. Step Up features Channing Tatum being Channing Tatum.
Why do movies like this continue to get made? How many times do we need to see students at an inner city school learn about life? Are we still in that mindset that kids are something to be scared of? Do we need to see that our students can in fact be reached? That they can become functional members of society? Or do we just want to see more movies with hip-hop soundtracks?
Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy movies like this. In the comments section of an earlier post, I mentioned that I have a (somewhat embarrassing) affection for the Step Up series. But these films rarely, if ever bring anything new to the equation, so why is it that they continue to be made?